Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
-
luceric
- Posts: 1252
- Joined: 21 Jun 2009, 22:08
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
The user guide does mention the sample workgroup in the intro. But the workgroup is just a set of samples to show programming examples, it's not the feature. ICE Kinematics is about allowing TDs to turn off all the built-in kinematics and override it completely with their own custom mathematics. And what to do next is not something that's necessarily teachable in the user guide, because it can be rig-specific and it's programming and math. ICE kinematics is basically an SDK feature, its a harness to allow doing something. If you're just looking to replace standard rig elements (example: constraints) with ICE nodes that do the same, there is really no gain, it doesn't bring better performance or better work flow to do the classic stuff. All the classic rigging tools are well implemented, optimized and well supported by existing tools, they're industry-standard and they are not obsolete. It's possible that in the future they'll be pre-built rigging tools that are implemented using ICE, but right now in 2011 the ICE Kinematic feature is only about opening up the connections for advanced riggers to build their rigs, and there is no shame in this. Therefore, the documentation is imho totally correct, because there is no hidden feature that's not being documented. In the same vein, we do not included a full introduction to shader programming in the rendering user guide, a course this size is just beyond what can be covered in a user's guide.
-
wacom
- Posts: 53
- Joined: 26 Apr 2010, 17:32
- Skype: gklindt
- Location: Oregon
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
luceric, what you say makes sense, though it would probably be appreciated by everyone, TD's included, if there were a few more scene examples packaged with the next major build of SI to look at and pull apart.
I understand though that just like when ICE was first released, hardly anyone had touched it outside a select few, so it was just a mater of time before the info, tutorials, and understanding came around.
To give the SI team credit, it's not as if the Houdini team has had all the time in the world to pump out tutorials and demos as their tech evolves quickly too. Though we, as SI users, hold you guys to a higher standard eh?
In terms of marketing, maybe we need to charter out a bunch of us to keep showing up at the next siggraph, GDC etc. walking around asking the AD reps showing off MAX and Maya where the SI booth and demonstrations are?
Maybe we can just pay a bunch of unemployed artists to do it- possibly some actors with thespian flair for extra drama? How about some street plays with SI staged as Malcolm and Macbeth as...
I understand though that just like when ICE was first released, hardly anyone had touched it outside a select few, so it was just a mater of time before the info, tutorials, and understanding came around.
To give the SI team credit, it's not as if the Houdini team has had all the time in the world to pump out tutorials and demos as their tech evolves quickly too. Though we, as SI users, hold you guys to a higher standard eh?
In terms of marketing, maybe we need to charter out a bunch of us to keep showing up at the next siggraph, GDC etc. walking around asking the AD reps showing off MAX and Maya where the SI booth and demonstrations are?
Maybe we can just pay a bunch of unemployed artists to do it- possibly some actors with thespian flair for extra drama? How about some street plays with SI staged as Malcolm and Macbeth as...
GIDEONKLINDT.COM
-
Hirazi Blue
- Administrator
- Posts: 5113
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 10:15
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
@luceric - First of all, I never said it was hidden feature, that's undocumented. IMHO the standard of its documentation just is not up to par with the well-crafted documentation of (X)SI versions of the past. This "figure it out yourself" mentality isn't really an improvement over the old way. But okay, whereas the User's Guide and accompanying tutorials of the old days used to care about teaching the user a trick or two, now we can probably only expect to fully understand new features, when we open up the User's Guide of our "companion product".

Stay safe, sane & healthy!
-
wacom
- Posts: 53
- Joined: 26 Apr 2010, 17:32
- Skype: gklindt
- Location: Oregon
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Maybe they should have called it "buddy product" or "interesting sidekick that actually upstages the lead role" or how about "Mysterious, sometimes emo, and often misunderstood, in the shadows companion product to big cheese app"?
I vote for "My-yah Buddy" personally.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vX9RSyotle8
I vote for "My-yah Buddy" personally.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vX9RSyotle8
Last edited by wacom on 29 Jul 2010, 16:14, edited 1 time in total.
GIDEONKLINDT.COM
-
Hirazi Blue
- Administrator
- Posts: 5113
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 10:15
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Please, don't get me wrong: the "companion" reference in this case was meant as a joke ;)
Stay safe, sane & healthy!
-
wacom
- Posts: 53
- Joined: 26 Apr 2010, 17:32
- Skype: gklindt
- Location: Oregon
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
I think your-Hirazi Blue wrote:Please, don't get me wrong: the "companion" reference in this case was meant as a joke ;)
In all seriousness, if they should just put SI in the first line for the premiums so that it reads "Max-SI Premium Bundle" or "Maya-SI Premium Bundle" Then list off what is in the packages (Maya, SI, Mudbox, etc.) There would be almost no extra confusion, it would calm the SI peoples fears, and it would assure a Max or Maya user that their bundle of choice comes with their program.
Hell, why are there not some banner ads on the Area and CGtalk that say something like "Two heads are better than one: Introducing Premium Suite Bundles from Autodesk." With a box shot of Maya/Max and SI, in that order, front and center, and then the others falling behind?
Regardless- if this were the last Quarter or what not, they could just spill the beans about what the next SI is, that yes, it is great, and it's own package, and look at all the new shinny toys- and we'd almost completely forget about this little "folly" in marketing on ADs point.
GIDEONKLINDT.COM
-
grahamef
- Posts: 281
- Joined: 23 Jun 2009, 19:01
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
It's pretty much the same situation once you get into advanced render tree stuff, e.g., once you get into ray-type switches and such. We don't document every possible variation on "How to drive X using Y" -- we couldn't possibly do that even if we tried. It's a matter of understanding the effect you want, the math behind it, and the nodes that you need to combine to achieve it.Hirazi Blue wrote:@luceric - First of all, I never said it was hidden feature, that's undocumented. IMHO the standard of its documentation just is not up to par with the well-crafted documentation of (X)SI versions of the past. This "figure it out yourself" mentality isn't really an improvement over the old way. But okay, whereas the User's Guide and accompanying tutorials of the old days used to care about teaching the user a trick or two, now we can probably only expect to fully understand new features, when we open up the User's Guide of our "companion product".
You probably don't expect a wordprocessor to teach you to be a great writer, and you probably don't expect a spreadsheet to teach you to be an accountant. In the same vein, you shouldn't expect the doc for 3D software to teach you about matrices, homogeneous coordinates, Jacobeans, cyclic coordinate descent, etc. Yet that's all stuff you're going to need to know once you start getting a bit deeper into kinematics.
It's possible that some time in the future we will wrap some of this up in friendlier compounds with easy-to-apply commands, or maybe some third party will. When that happens, there'll be full doc for the workflow. But it's not there right now, so we can't write about it yet.
Last edited by grahamef on 29 Jul 2010, 17:36, edited 1 time in total.
-
Hirazi Blue
- Administrator
- Posts: 5113
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 10:15
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Well, the word processor and spreadsheet analogy seem a bit strange, but okay...
That's probably your reaction to my "companion" joke.
This leaves me with the distinct feeling, however,
that the normal (as in "generalist") user doesn't really matter to you anymore.
It's "easy" to create tools, if you don't really feel the need to document them...
(Show one video with Mark Schoennagel demoing the feature and you're done...
)
(edited slightly)
That's probably your reaction to my "companion" joke.
This leaves me with the distinct feeling, however,
that the normal (as in "generalist") user doesn't really matter to you anymore.
It's "easy" to create tools, if you don't really feel the need to document them...
(Show one video with Mark Schoennagel demoing the feature and you're done...
(edited slightly)
Stay safe, sane & healthy!
-
wacom
- Posts: 53
- Joined: 26 Apr 2010, 17:32
- Skype: gklindt
- Location: Oregon
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Hirazi- I mean no offense, but are you having a bad day/week or something?
Really, I'm not entirely pleased with the marketing either, but grahamef is about the last person in the SI team to blow smoke. His analogy IMHO IS correct.
Could things be better, could they have someone make a few more compounds for average Joe 3D user to look at and work with? Sure thing. As it stands though, ICE is still rather early in use and public development. If you compare it to Houdini, then I'd say it's doing well on this front.
All the user friendly tools are still there, still supported, and still awesome IMHO. Granted, they could throw us a bone or two in terms of features NOT directly related to ICE (or maybe are ICE under the hood, but to Joe user just an op), but it's not like the app is broken in these areas IMHO.
OK, one gripe. The old particles sucked, but they were good for quick and dirty simple stuff. Why did they have to jettison them? They need to have a replacement IMHO- and some other tools for the FX crowd (as seen in other threads).
You don't have to be a mad scientist to take advantage of ICE, just like you don't have to know the ins and outs of ray tracing to use the basics render tree or the render settings. The same holds true though if you want to go further, as grahamef has stated, and frankly, IK is probably, AFAIK, one of the more complicated areas of CG outside of render engines and even many simulations.
However, it is understandable that users such as ourselves would like to harness that power given that many of us use IK all the time for animation etc. So we feel close to it even if we don't understand it.
I feel like you are basically asking for more compounds for semi-savvy users to use and are sick of the SI team waiting for a 3rd party to fill in the gap (which they are). Again, no offense, you are the moderator here, but can you focus on requesting this in a more constructive way than threatening to jump ship, and saying the boat is sinking, when to everyone else it sailing along just fine (even if we don't like the flag being flown)?
Really, I'm not entirely pleased with the marketing either, but grahamef is about the last person in the SI team to blow smoke. His analogy IMHO IS correct.
Could things be better, could they have someone make a few more compounds for average Joe 3D user to look at and work with? Sure thing. As it stands though, ICE is still rather early in use and public development. If you compare it to Houdini, then I'd say it's doing well on this front.
All the user friendly tools are still there, still supported, and still awesome IMHO. Granted, they could throw us a bone or two in terms of features NOT directly related to ICE (or maybe are ICE under the hood, but to Joe user just an op), but it's not like the app is broken in these areas IMHO.
OK, one gripe. The old particles sucked, but they were good for quick and dirty simple stuff. Why did they have to jettison them? They need to have a replacement IMHO- and some other tools for the FX crowd (as seen in other threads).
You don't have to be a mad scientist to take advantage of ICE, just like you don't have to know the ins and outs of ray tracing to use the basics render tree or the render settings. The same holds true though if you want to go further, as grahamef has stated, and frankly, IK is probably, AFAIK, one of the more complicated areas of CG outside of render engines and even many simulations.
However, it is understandable that users such as ourselves would like to harness that power given that many of us use IK all the time for animation etc. So we feel close to it even if we don't understand it.
I feel like you are basically asking for more compounds for semi-savvy users to use and are sick of the SI team waiting for a 3rd party to fill in the gap (which they are). Again, no offense, you are the moderator here, but can you focus on requesting this in a more constructive way than threatening to jump ship, and saying the boat is sinking, when to everyone else it sailing along just fine (even if we don't like the flag being flown)?
GIDEONKLINDT.COM
-
Hirazi Blue
- Administrator
- Posts: 5113
- Joined: 04 Jun 2009, 10:15
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Yes, you're right, I'm having a very bad day... Sorry...
But why is every criticism perceived as a "call to jump ship" (or a "conspiracy theory" for that matter)? I vented my personal opinion on a topic and the reaction I got. End of story. I did this a bit harshly, for which I apologize.
Not the (or my) end of Softimage as far as I am concerned...
But why is every criticism perceived as a "call to jump ship" (or a "conspiracy theory" for that matter)? I vented my personal opinion on a topic and the reaction I got. End of story. I did this a bit harshly, for which I apologize.
Not the (or my) end of Softimage as far as I am concerned...
Stay safe, sane & healthy!
-
wacom
- Posts: 53
- Joined: 26 Apr 2010, 17:32
- Skype: gklindt
- Location: Oregon
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Hey, no problem eh Hirazi?
I think most of us agree, even if the SI team can't speak, that AD's marketing of si could be better, no mater how they want to color it. The way it is currently handled leads to a constant back lash from the some of the user base who see it as proof that si is the "red headed step child" of AD, and it doesn't help give si the needed exposure it deserves helping move seats of it.
To make things worse, there is inconstancy between all areas of the Autodesk site in terms of why certain products are listed in certain areas or not.
Many of these issues could be easily, and inexpensively corrected, or at least improved enough to settle down the user base and assure the si community that all is well with si and AD.
The way the current bundle has SI seeming more like a "companion" merely whipped back up into flame an issue which had never fully settled after the acquisition from AD.
In the end, it is a shame that the people working for AD support, documentation, tech etc. in the si team have to often be the ones that come on places like here and calm us down. It's a serious waste of resources that just a few extra words on a site or press release, and a couple of images, would prevent from ever happening.
I think most of us agree, even if the SI team can't speak, that AD's marketing of si could be better, no mater how they want to color it. The way it is currently handled leads to a constant back lash from the some of the user base who see it as proof that si is the "red headed step child" of AD, and it doesn't help give si the needed exposure it deserves helping move seats of it.
To make things worse, there is inconstancy between all areas of the Autodesk site in terms of why certain products are listed in certain areas or not.
Many of these issues could be easily, and inexpensively corrected, or at least improved enough to settle down the user base and assure the si community that all is well with si and AD.
The way the current bundle has SI seeming more like a "companion" merely whipped back up into flame an issue which had never fully settled after the acquisition from AD.
In the end, it is a shame that the people working for AD support, documentation, tech etc. in the si team have to often be the ones that come on places like here and calm us down. It's a serious waste of resources that just a few extra words on a site or press release, and a couple of images, would prevent from ever happening.
GIDEONKLINDT.COM
-
electricgeisha
- Posts: 28
- Joined: 07 Jul 2010, 13:25
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
I don't think anyone has been rude or threating (jumping ship etc). We had a discussion last week on a similar topic we were reassured things are fine and dandy... we accepted that (still accept that, LOVE SI! we would not be here discussing it if we didn't.)
It just came as a shock the following week after being reassured that it was thrown into a bundle with the MAYA/MAX products... it does make you raise your eyebrows.
I don't think anyone needs to apologize for asking questions etc.. and maybe we throw some sarcasm in for forum entertainment but lets remember it is software we are talking about not the demise of humanity.
But why not be passionate about SI in my opinion it is the only worthy app worth getting feisty about. And lets be honest if the Maya community had their "precious" thrown through hoops.... them Mayan's can get realllll nasty
It just came as a shock the following week after being reassured that it was thrown into a bundle with the MAYA/MAX products... it does make you raise your eyebrows.
I don't think anyone needs to apologize for asking questions etc.. and maybe we throw some sarcasm in for forum entertainment but lets remember it is software we are talking about not the demise of humanity.
But why not be passionate about SI in my opinion it is the only worthy app worth getting feisty about. And lets be honest if the Maya community had their "precious" thrown through hoops.... them Mayan's can get realllll nasty
-
Gabba
- Posts: 35
- Joined: 18 Apr 2010, 12:31
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
This post is going to be a provocation (not totally...).
Present:
The companies that uses Maya and Max want Softimage mainly for ICE.
Most of those companies, I think, have a subscription or have subscription contracts.
Softimage "subscription advantage pack" would include Lagoa and empolygonizer.
Future:
Maya and Max "companies" have the possibility to purchase Softimage in Bundle.
Softimage would have a particle physic-based plug-ing for free if under subscription.
Softimage would have an export mesher for free if under subscription.
Result?
Maya and Max "users" can have ICE integrated in their workflow using Lagoa for physically things based passing by emPolygonizer as exporter...
It feels a little strange that this bundle come out at the same time as the "Lagoa Upgrade". Why not implement those feature in the 2011.5?? It seems a lure to catch as most users as possible. "You can have this bundle AND if you subscribe (most of them are doing it already I think) you can have also those "tasty" plug-ins!". Why this, other than get more revenue? Don't know. Let's time tell us this ;)
Present:
The companies that uses Maya and Max want Softimage mainly for ICE.
Most of those companies, I think, have a subscription or have subscription contracts.
Softimage "subscription advantage pack" would include Lagoa and empolygonizer.
Future:
Maya and Max "companies" have the possibility to purchase Softimage in Bundle.
Softimage would have a particle physic-based plug-ing for free if under subscription.
Softimage would have an export mesher for free if under subscription.
Result?
Maya and Max "users" can have ICE integrated in their workflow using Lagoa for physically things based passing by emPolygonizer as exporter...
It feels a little strange that this bundle come out at the same time as the "Lagoa Upgrade". Why not implement those feature in the 2011.5?? It seems a lure to catch as most users as possible. "You can have this bundle AND if you subscribe (most of them are doing it already I think) you can have also those "tasty" plug-ins!". Why this, other than get more revenue? Don't know. Let's time tell us this ;)
-
luceric
- Posts: 1252
- Joined: 21 Jun 2009, 22:08
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Softimage Subscription Advantage Pack *is* Softimage 2011.5 (available to Softimage Subscription clients only)
and the soon-to-be-released Premium Suite will include the "Subscription Advantage Pack" versions of all application in the suite and I think requires purchasing subscription.
and the soon-to-be-released Premium Suite will include the "Subscription Advantage Pack" versions of all application in the suite and I think requires purchasing subscription.
Last edited by luceric on 31 Aug 2010, 14:33, edited 1 time in total.
-
Gabba
- Posts: 35
- Joined: 18 Apr 2010, 12:31
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
Thanky luceric for this clarification ;)luceric wrote:Softimage Subscription Advantage Pack *is* Softimage 2011.5 (available to Softimage Subscription clients only)
and the soon-to-be-released Premium Suite will include the "Subscription Advantage Pack" versions of all application of all the apps in the suite and I think requires purchasing subscription.
-
Bellsey
- Posts: 688
- Joined: 19 Apr 2010, 09:50
- Location: London, UnitedKingdom
Re: Umm I think we meant why doesn't SI have its OWN!
To the best of my knowledge if you purchase an Entertainment Creation Suite Premium, you don't have to buy Subscription as well to get things like the Softimage Advantage Pack.
It's included in the Suite because the Entertainment Creation Suite Premium will be a new product.
Of course you can still purchase Subscription for the Entertainment Creation Suites if you want to.
If you just own Softimage 2011 and no Suites, then the Softimage Advantage Pack is avalaible to Softimage Subscription customers only.
It's included in the Suite because the Entertainment Creation Suite Premium will be a new product.
Of course you can still purchase Subscription for the Entertainment Creation Suites if you want to.
If you just own Softimage 2011 and no Suites, then the Softimage Advantage Pack is avalaible to Softimage Subscription customers only.