septopus wrote:
well there is no point in arguing s letter box still hosts other tuts.
but if i recall correctly, these dvds from 3d tutorial had a big announcement on the base and your blog that they were being "given" away free. no guidelines given when you gave them away; in fact the community was encouraged to share...
moving on. it was a nice [short lived] gesture

Nearly correct

Letterbox only had a "temporary" right to distribute them but they had no actual rights beyond that, certainly not in the IP, nor could they assign or transfer any rights to any other party. Moreover, my agreement with Letterbox was that all original copyright notices must remain intact and that at no time could they or anyone else ever charge a fee for the material. So the upshot is that Letterbox had/has no right whatsoever in this material, other than to act as a temporary distributor for a finite period of time. No guarantees were ever made as to the length of time that this material would remain freely available.
But look, it's not a big deal really because you and I both know that ALL this material can be found via torrents and on the P2P networks, so that is the reality. I keep a close eye on the underground scene and my material turns up all the time, so if you really want to find it... it is floating around cyberspace..somewhere.
Like I said, I think I've been a pretty helpful guy. Hey remember, I'm the person who made the investment in time and money to create this material in the first place, so I think I have every right to have the final say about what happens to it. Also, for the record, I made ALL the skeleton keys available to anyone who wanted them for more than a year before Letterbox even became involved, so the gesture was in fact not that short lived

Again guys, not trying to be a PITA
Joe